Internal Predators vs. External Threats: Rebalancing Church Security Priorities

In recent months, North Texas has emerged as a critical example in the nationwide conversation about sexual misconduct within churches. A series of high-profile resignations and dismissals among pastors from prominent megachurches have exposed deep-seated issues that threaten the very foundation of congregational trust. These departures, driven by allegations ranging from moral failures and inappropriate behavior to outright sexual abuse, not only tarnish the reputations of individual churches but also impede their broader mission of attracting new followers of Christ. As North Texas grapples with this crisis, the lessons learned here offer important insights for churches across the nation striving to protect their congregations and uphold their spiritual integrity.

The North Texas Crisis: A Microcosm of a Nationwide Problem

A Surge of Misconduct Allegations

Since May, at least seven pastors from major North Texas megachurches have either resigned or been dismissed amid serious allegations. These cases encompass a range of misconduct, including sexual assault, inappropriate relationships, and other moral failings. The most notable among them include:

• Josiah Anthony – Cross Timbers Church, Argyle: Resigned in late July following reports of inappropriate communication with two women. While the church clarified that Anthony's actions did not involve illegal activity or interactions with children, the nature of his communications—ranging from excessively personal to sexually suggestive—highlight the precarious balance of power within church leadership.

• Robert Morris – Gateway Church, Southlake: Admitted to "sexually inappropriate behavior" after being accused of sexually abusing Cindy Clemshire when she was just 12 years old. Morris's resignation on June 18 led to a cascade of departures, including his wife, son, and several church elders, underscoring the profound impact of such revelations.

• Luke Cunningham – Lakeside Baptist Church, Granbury: Suspended and subsequently fired after evidence surfaced of his sexual assault of a minor between 2016 and 2018. Cunningham's arrest on multiple charges, including aggravated sexual assault of a child, illustrates the severe legal consequences that can follow such misconduct.

• Ronald Goines – Koinonia Church, Arlington: Arrested on July 25 for indecent and sexual assault. The church swiftly appointed a new lead pastor, focusing on Goines' healing and restoration.

• Tony Cammarota – Stonebriar Community Church, Frisco: Fired after confessing to a "moral failure" following 17 years of service, prompting the church to caution against speculation and protect the community from further damage.

• Tony Evans – Oak Cliff Bible Fellowship Church, Dallas: Announced his departure on June 9 due to an undisclosed "sin," acknowledging a lapse in righteous judgment and committing to a healing and restoration process.

• Terren Dames – North Dallas Community Bible Fellowship, Plano: Arrested in May for solicitation of prostitution and removed from his position immediately, highlighting the swift actions taken to address such misconduct.

Impact on Congregations and Church Reputation

These high-profile cases have profound implications for congregations:

• Loss of Trust: When church leaders—those entrusted with spiritual guidance and moral authority—are implicated in misconduct, it creates a significant breach of trust. Congregants may begin to question the integrity of their spiritual leaders, leading to decreased attendance and skepticism towards church leadership. Some of these same people are leaving organized church services for good.

• Declining Attendance: As trust wanes, existing members may leave, and potential new members may be deterred from joining, fearing similar misconduct. This decline not only affects individual churches but also diminishes the collective reputation of religious institutions, impacting their ability to fulfill their missions within the community.

• Community Impact: The reputational damage extends beyond the church walls, affecting the broader community’s perception of religious institutions. This erosion of trust can lead to decreased community engagement and support, further isolating churches from the very communities they aim to serve.

Michelle Simpson Tuegel, a Dallas-based victims’ rights attorney, describes the recent wave of accusations as a "domino effect," where the courage of one survivor encourages others to come forward. This phenomenon is particularly prevalent in large institutions like megachurches, where the pursuit of growth and profit can overshadow the well-being of congregants. Tuegel emphasizes that blatant signs of abuse are often ignored or covered up, creating an environment where misconduct can thrive in secrecy. The sheer scale and financial influence of megachurches can create a protective bubble, making it easier for abusers to exploit their positions without immediate repercussions.

Pete Singer, executive director of Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment (GRACE), stresses the importance of transparency in addressing abuse within churches. He argues that vague statements about a pastor’s resignation without providing details do little to inform and protect the congregation. "People who abuse put a lot of effort into being the kind of person that would make you say they’d never do that," Singer explains, highlighting the manipulative nature of abusers who maintain a facade of respectability and trustworthiness.

Understanding the Patterns: Why Misconduct Persists in Churches

The Power Dynamics Within Churches

One of the critical factors contributing to the persistence of misconduct within churches is the inherent power dynamic between pastors and congregants. Pastors often hold significant influence and authority, making it easier for them to manipulate and exploit their positions. This imbalance can create an environment where abuse can occur unchecked, as congregants may feel powerless to speak out or fear retaliation.

Lack of Accountability and Oversight

Many megachurches, driven by substantial profits and growth ambitions, often lack adequate oversight and accountability mechanisms. This absence can inadvertently allow abusive behavior to persist, as there may be insufficient checks and balances to prevent misconduct. In some cases, church leadership may prioritize maintaining the church's reputation and financial stability over addressing allegations of abuse, leading to cover-ups and silencing of victims.

Cultural and Structural Barriers to Reporting

Cultural and structural barriers within churches can also hinder the reporting and addressing of misconduct. Victims may feel shame, fear retribution, or believe that their claims will not be taken seriously. Additionally, the hierarchical structure of many churches can make it difficult for victims to report abuse without facing significant personal and spiritual repercussions.

The Critical Need for Balancing Security Focus: Internal vs. External Threats

Overemphasis on External Threats

While many churches prepare extensively for violent threats, such as active shooter scenarios, the prevalence of sexual crimes—often perpetrated by trusted leaders—remains alarmingly high. Sexual assault within churches, particularly by pastors and staff members, dominates discussions in my weekly bulletins dedicated to church crime, surpassing even crimes against persons (assaults, shootings, stabbings). This discrepancy highlights a critical oversight in church security strategies, where the focus on external threats may inadvertently neglect the more insidious dangers posed by internal misconduct.

Underestimated Internal Threats

The threat of a sexual predator working within a church is a more immediate and likely danger compared to the minimal, albeit serious, risk of an active shooter. However, many churches do not prioritize training or implementing policies to address this internal threat. This lack of focus leaves congregations vulnerable to abuse by those who are meant to protect and lead them, undermining the very safety and trust that churches are meant to foster.

The Importance of Comprehensive Security Training

To effectively protect congregations, churches must adopt a comprehensive approach to security that addresses both external and internal threats. This includes not only preparing for potential violent incidents but also implementing robust safeguards against sexual misconduct. By balancing their security focus, churches can create a safer and more trusting environment for all members.

The Role of Church Security Teams in Preventing Misconduct

Implementing Strong Policies

To address and prevent misconduct, church security teams must take a proactive stance. Implementing strong policies is paramount. Churches need to develop comprehensive guidelines that clearly define acceptable behavior, outline reporting procedures, and specify consequences for misconduct. These policies should be easily accessible to all church members and staff, ensuring that everyone is aware of the standards and protocols in place. Clear policies not only provide a framework for addressing misconduct but also signal the church's commitment to maintaining a safe and respectful environment.

Conducting Rigorous Background Checks

Rigorous background checks are another critical component in safeguarding congregations. Churches must perform thorough screenings for all staff and volunteers, focusing on criminal history, especially related to sexual offenses. Regularly updating and reviewing these background checks can help maintain current information and prevent individuals with a history of misconduct from gaining positions of influence within the church. Comprehensive background checks serve as a preventive measure, reducing the risk of hiring individuals who may pose a threat to congregants.

Continuous Monitoring and Training

Continuous monitoring and training are essential in maintaining a safe environment. Establishing ongoing monitoring systems allows churches to detect and address any signs of inappropriate behavior early. Regular training for church security teams and staff on identifying and responding to potential red flags can equip them with the tools needed to prevent misconduct before it occurs. This proactive approach can significantly reduce the risk of abuse within church settings, ensuring that church leaders and staff are prepared to handle potential issues effectively.

Fostering a Culture of Transparency

Fostering a culture of transparency is equally important. Churches should encourage open communication and ensure that any allegations are promptly and transparently addressed. Creating safe channels for victims and witnesses to report misconduct without fear of retaliation is crucial in building trust and ensuring that abuse does not go unchecked. Transparency not only protects victims but also reinforces the church’s commitment to maintaining a safe and respectful environment for all members.

Supporting Victims with Tough Systems

Support systems for victims must be strong and readily available. Churches should offer counseling and support services for those affected by abuse, ensuring they have the resources needed to heal. Providing comprehensive support for victims is essential in fostering an environment where survivors feel valued and protected.

What Your Safety Ministry Can Do

Adopting Comprehensive Safeguarding Policies

To restore trust and prevent future incidents, churches must lead with integrity and accountability. Adopting comprehensive safeguarding policies is the first step towards creating a secure environment. These policies should establish clear guidelines that protect vulnerable members and outline strict protocols for handling allegations. Implementing independent oversight committees to regularly review church practices can ensure compliance with safeguarding policies and provide an additional layer of accountability.

Enhancing Oversight Mechanisms

Enhancing oversight mechanisms is crucial in maintaining ongoing accountability. Independent oversight committees can provide objective evaluations of church practices, ensuring that safeguarding policies are adhered to and that any deviations are promptly addressed. Regular audits and reviews can help identify potential vulnerabilities and implement necessary adjustments to strengthen the church’s protective measures.

Promoting Ethical Leadership

Promoting ethical leadership is another crucial element in restoring trust. Church leaders must uphold high ethical standards and model appropriate behavior, setting a positive example for the entire congregation. Ethical leadership fosters a culture of integrity and respect, making it less likely for misconduct to occur and more likely for abuse to be addressed promptly if it does. Leaders who prioritize ethical behavior inspire confidence and trust among congregants, reinforcing the church’s commitment to maintaining a safe and supportive environment.

Engaging the Congregation in Safeguarding Efforts

Engaging the congregation in creating a safe environment is vital. Involving church members in the development and implementation of safeguarding measures fosters a sense of collective responsibility for maintaining integrity within the church. When congregants feel empowered to hold leaders accountable and support one another, the entire community benefits from a safer and more respectful environment. Educational programs and open forums can encourage active participation and dialogue, strengthening the church’s overall safeguarding efforts.

Utilizing Technology and Resources for Better Protection

Leveraging technology and available resources can enhance the effectiveness of safeguarding measures. Implementing secure reporting systems, such as anonymous online forms or dedicated hotlines, can facilitate easier reporting of misconduct. Additionally, utilizing management software to track background checks, training completion, and incident reports can help churches stay organized and responsive to potential issues. By embracing technological solutions, churches can streamline their safeguarding processes and ensure that all necessary measures are in place to protect their congregations.

Conclusion

The challenges faced by North Texas churches are a microcosm of a broader issue affecting religious institutions across the nation. The erosion of trust due to sexual misconduct by church leaders is a profound problem that demands immediate and sustained action. By adopting comprehensive safeguarding policies, conducting rigorous background checks, fostering a culture of transparency, and supporting victims, churches can protect their congregations and rebuild the trust that is essential for their spiritual mission.

The path forward requires unwavering commitment from church leadership and active participation from the entire congregation to ensure that churches remain sanctuaries of hope, safety, and spiritual growth for all. By learning from the North Texas debacle and implementing effective measures, churches nationwide can safeguard their communities, restore trust, and continue their vital work in guiding individuals towards faith and fulfillment.

---

Additional Resources

• Safeguarding Against Sexual Abuse – A comprehensive guide on preventing sexual misconduct within church environments.